I would narrow it down to 15's or 16's, seventeens are too much weight, and they don't leave enough tire, plus I hate how they look.

16's (Enkei RSF-2)



15's (Rota Circuit 8) btw, no complaints on the Rota's///

 

^ that's a sexy teg.

I'd say if you want to go for all-out performance or if you want the jdm look, go with 15's.
If you just want something that looks better than stock and don't care about the jdm vs. usdm thing, go with 16's.

 

This place is just down the street from me and I intend to get some 15s or 16s from them when the present tires are worn out. Rotas appear to be good wheels for the price.